Are ice baths worth the agony?

In the past, after any long run of 18 or more, I’d take a cold water bath (too wimpy to go all the way to ice!). I swore by them for recovery. Only 10 minutes would be enough to make a difference for me.

icebath Are ice baths worth the agony?

This might be taking it to an extreme!

This year, however, I haven’t been able to coax myself into the cold water; not sure why, but I can’t seem to handle them anymore. The interesting thing? I don’t notice any difference. In fact, I’ve mentioned before that I am recovering faster/better than ever before this year, which I chalk up to better running form. Whatever the case, it turns out that ice baths may not be the cure all for recovery that many of us think anyhow.

I did a little research into it, and the evidence on ice baths is conflicting at best. Some, like this one, show that the cold water does a great job at jump starting your muscles recovery process. Other studies, however, claim that ice baths do no good and in fact, might even stall recovery.

Hard to know what do do, but I’d stick with this–if it seems to work for you, do it. If not, then don’t put yourself through the torture just because you think it’s the right thing. I can’t say that I miss my time in the cold water this year!

Do you take ice/cold water baths after long runs? 

pin it button Are ice baths worth the agony?

Related Posts:

Comments

  1. Yes, I take ice baths after long runs. I also took ice baths when recovering from shin splints. It is hell sitting in an ice bath for 20 minutes, but it sure helps my muscles bounce back a little faster.
    Ara recently posted..Processed FoodsMy Profile

  2. I accosted Tricia Minnick about this and she keeps saying HELLS YES :)
    Miz recently posted..Wordless Wednessday: before and after?My Profile

  3. I can take them or leave them. They seem to “feel” good after a long run where I really hurt, but “feeling” good oesn’t necessarily mean it’s actually doing anything.
    Jamoosh recently posted..Cross Training: Good, Bad, IndifferentMy Profile

  4. I have never ever taken an ice bath and have no plans to. They freak me out. =)
    Heidi @BananaBuzzbomb recently posted..Running Isn’t Fun – Let’s Get Back To BasicsMy Profile

  5. I’ve never taken an ice bath but I swear by epson salt baths…..maybe I’ll conduct a “scientific experiment” this summer :)
    Heather@Just a Colorado Gal recently posted..We Live in a Beautiful WorldMy Profile

  6. I usually do ice baths after my long runs but what I think actually helps me more is stretching and/or hitting up pilates class post run. That really keeps me from being sore the next day.
    J recently posted..Confessions of a First Time MarathonerMy Profile

  7. I do half ice baths. I can’t get the water above my ankles so only my hamstrings and calves get to soak in the ice. I feel like ice has really helped me recover lately, so while I hate them, I forced myself in one on Saturday.
    Robin recently posted..Taper Time for Boston & Boston.com BloggerMy Profile

  8. I tried ice baths a couple of times, but I found that compression during runs and after worked better for me. That and I hate the freezing cold.
    kari @ Running Ricig recently posted..my new best friendMy Profile

  9. I love the way you approached this – sometimes I feel like I am rereading another article in someone’s post !!
    I don’t ice bath. I always say I should, but then I wonder, why? I have never been injured and have never had any recovery issues after a long run. I stretch a bit but find that the best remedy for me is a 5-7 mile shakeout run the next day.
    Michele @ nycrunningmama recently posted..Post-Pregnancy GoalMy Profile

  10. I tried cold baths, but I am not sure if they really help, and since I only have a shower at home, I sometimes shower my legs with the coldest water possible, but I also do that when I didn’t just came back from a run. I just think it’s really refreshing!
    Nina recently posted..Running-HomeMy Profile

  11. I don’t ice bath, I had read a couple months ago about how a study at the U of Montana showed they really didn’t do much good and could slow the recovery process. Doesn’t break my heart it never sounded fun to me anyway!
    Christy@My Dirt Road Anthem recently posted..21 is in the bag.My Profile

  12. Ahhh I too have wondered the same thing! I have NOT put my body in ice once so far and well.. I”m still here I wonder about the so called bene’s
    Mamarunsbarefoot recently posted..Two FirstsMy Profile

  13. I’ve done the research as well and have seen a lot of conflicting evidence that it does not help recovery, it’s really only good for inflammation. I tend to follow more Eastern medicine for recovery which doesn’t believe that much in icing. Here’s a good article I read on when to ice and when to use heat:

    http://www.yourdrgreens.com/blog/tag/chimat/
    Kristy (@KrisRunTri) recently posted..Taking Running Advice From Kenny RogersMy Profile

  14. I’ve often wondered about icing. I think if it’s giving you a huge benefit, then you need to examine other aspects of your running. Ice will decrease inflammation….but why are you inflamed?
    Ice works for immediate injuries, but I would rather not slow blood flow to an area in recovery.
    Like you, I think if it works for you, good; if not, skip it!
    Gracie recently posted..I got my Boston bib number!My Profile

  15. I can’t even swim in a competition pool because it’s too cold. I’m so anti ice bath it’s not funny. But I agree, if it works for you, keep it up. What works for me is a steaming hot, HOT bath.
    Joanne recently posted..Nutritional GoodiesMy Profile

  16. I wouldn’t do a full on ice bath but instead I would get a tall bucket that came up to my knees and ice from the knees down. I think maybe it helped a little but I’ve only done it on my 15 milers or longer.
    Coy recently posted..When the going gets tough, the tough "just keep swimming"My Profile

  17. I don’t currently do them, but was planning to during my next marathon training cycle this summer. I’ve seen so many poeple tout their magical powers, it’s interesting to see other people’s experiences as well.
    runblondie26 recently posted..Beer in Bruges, Chocolate Truffles in BrusselsMy Profile

  18. I’ve never taken an ice bath, and probably never will. I will take a cool bath, however, but not so much for recover as for lowering my body temperature after a hot run. Instead, I prefer compression and super-slow recovery runs more beneficial after long runs/races.
    Viper recently posted..The Short Shake OutMy Profile

  19. I find them helpful. I didn’t after my race on Sunday…and paid the price big.time. They are so tough to do in the winter so I tend to be kind of wussy then.
    I always start with cool-ish water and keep making it colder and colder then add the ice.
    Laura recently posted..Around the Bay Race Report – when you do everything right but it feels so wrongMy Profile

  20. I’ve never taken a ice bath and have no plans to start. For me it’s because the majority of articles I’ve read concluded that ice baths produce a “placebo effect” rather than significant recovery benefits. So I’ll stick with stretching!
    Theresa @ActiveEggplant recently posted..InsanityMy Profile

  21. I took my first one of the season this weekend and I DO think they help me. I’m going to continue on…they hurt so good :p
    Julie recently posted..Biggest LoserMy Profile

  22. It took me one ice bath to realize….NO THANK YOU!!! I will find other ways to recover!
    Fancy Nancy recently posted..Talk to Me TuesdayMy Profile

  23. I go back and forth on this. I think it helps after a long hard effort, but sometimes I’m too lazy to do it and don’t really notice a difference?
    katie recently posted..wordless wednesday: ass & puppyMy Profile

  24. I’m too wimpy for the ice but can handle the cold baths and it seems to help. But as my video the other day showed…it wasn’t drama free.

  25. I did them all the time in college at the trainer’s.. it’s a little more inconvenient to do them now. Those first 3 minutes before the numbness is total agony.. Now I usually only do them after big races and I think they help when your legs are aching from the inflammation. And I always take at least 1 total recovery day after a big race. :)
    Amy (@RunningArmyWife) recently posted..Things I Love LatelyMy Profile

  26. I used to ice bath religiously, after any run over 10 miles. Then I stopped. And I don’t really notice any difference. I probably feel better with foam rolling religiously, than I ever did in the ice bath.
    Heather recently posted..Plan for the Week….My Profile

  27. I’ve maaaaybe taken 3 ice baths in my entire life. My XC coach in college used to tell us we had the option to do it if we wanted, but few of us ever did. And we were all super strong, injury-free, healthy D3 athletes. I’ve tried a few times, but dang it they HURT. My heart literally feels like it’s going to stop. Not worth it to me :)
    Erin recently posted..Gearing up for my first ride of the season and the Nuggets gameMy Profile

  28. you said it, sister! I’m not into doing what everyone else does for their fitness “just because”. Took me a while to learn that, but I rock at it now and much happier for it.
    Yum Yucky recently posted..24-Hour Workout Will Melt Your Fat Slabs FasterMy Profile

  29. I take ice baths after anything over 16 miles or so. I would love to know if it didn’t really help since it is self-induced torture :) but I am a believer and have noticed a difference when I have skipped it.
    Erin Henderson recently posted..StrengthMy Profile

  30. Being as my “long runs” haven’t been too long lately, I haven’t had reason for an ice bath in about a year. But, when I was marathon training I took several, and I definitely felt like they helped. I did a 9 hour adventure race the day after a terrible 20 mile run, and I could barely walk at the end of the run. I attribute that to the ice, because I”m sure not that tough!
    Kate recently posted..She said: LBL Challenge 24-hour Adventure Race (part 1)My Profile

  31. Caroline72 says:
  32. I am going to be blunt here: F ice baths. Not for me. Did them a few times and hated them because I am a cold water wimp.

    I now use Arctic Ease but I have a rule that the run/bike/swim or overall training has to be more than 2 hours otherwise I just plop on compression sleeves/socks.

    And still I don’t stretch after either…..take that science……haha!
    Jason @ Cook Train Eat Race recently posted..Polenta Fries and SausageMy Profile

  33. I love/hate my ice baths, but it has to be after a long run. To me it is also like a badge of honor type thing. Does it work? I dunno, just like shaving my leggs doesn;t really make me faster, but I still do it.
    James recently posted..That’s What She Said!My Profile

  34. No ice baths for me. Research has popped up recently like you said that an ice bath can prevent recovery, so because I don’t like to be cold I’m going with that. In fact ever since I have stopped icing and static stretching I haven’t had any injuries, and that has been about 3 years. But who really knows, these days there are so many bogus articles out there that it’s hard to believe anything.
    Britt @ Chicago Runner Girl recently posted..CHM Training Week 8 RecapMy Profile

  35. Did an ice bath once and it was brutal! It’s funny I was just reading a debate among some runners on FB about ice vs. epsom salts. I’d never tried epsom salts so I gave it a whirl and I will say it was a thousand times more enjoyable – jury’s still our for me on the speed of recovery, but I’ll probably try it again.
    Michelle @ Running with Attitude recently posted..Shaking up my trainingMy Profile

  36. Well I’m glad you posed this question because it’s one I had as well. I’ts interesting to see all the replies here. I am planning on doing them this training season but never have before. Very curious to see how my legs react!
    Ericka @ The Sweet Life recently posted..10 Books You Should ReadMy Profile

  37. I took them a couple of times after my long runs, but I did not notice any difference in my recovery, plus they were uncomfortable, so I stopped. I don’t feel like they are necessary to me. So I don’t take them anymore.
    Kyria recently posted..Movie BuffMy Profile

  38. i never take them and when i tried them i never noticed a substanial difference. i think compression gear post-run works way better…without the coldness!
    Kristy recently posted..Boston Week 12 RecapMy Profile

  39. I would rather do ANYTHING than take an ice bath. I find it more torturous than the last 6.2 miles in a marathon. Recent buzz had me convinced I should try it again this last weekend after a 20 miler, and after I did…I swore I would never do it again. Glad to know I’m not the only one. Call me ‘wimp’, I don’t care. ;)

  40. i always kind of liked them. i haven’t done anything worthy of needing to ice in quite some time of course, but i think i felt slightly ‘refreshed’ after doing them. yes they hurt, and it’s a little miserable at first, but i’m weird and kinda like that pain. haha.
    lindsay recently posted..shake it like a salt shakerMy Profile

  41. I have a well on my property. The water out of it is freezing cold. No ice really needed. I slowly add water to an empty tub and it’s not that bad. I do believe in icing. I didn’t use them until this past year. If my recover time is any indication, they work for me. And a little quiet time after a race is something only hiding in the bathroom can provide at my house! ;-)
    shelly recently posted..L.O. & TsMy Profile

  42. I “USED TO” be soooooooooooooo good about icing. now….it’s about once every two months.

    Just being lazy. It always works when I do it.

  43. right now I am using my pool!
    the water is really cold.
    I put my legs in it for 10 min. it does help me.
    Caroline recently posted..The OneMy Profile

  44. I think they feel good at the time you’re emerged in the cold water, but they don”t do anything to speed up recovery or make me feel any better after. I’m a 50/50 if take one or not, and I definitely don’t in the winter. Brrr.
    Jill recently posted..The 50k That Wasn’t RRMy Profile

  45. When I was new to this endurance stuff “Ice baths” were very frequent. Just thought it was something I had to do to speed up recovery.

    Now I only use ice when something is sore or strained and it is in a ziplock bag!

    Like you, I have done a bunch of reading about the benefits (or lack there of) and the research seems to indicate that they really do nothing for recovery.

    Also like you, I have found that recovery is aided by short, slow runs/rides/swims and the volume that is added also increases fitness so I’d rather spend my time doing that then freezing my ass off in a tub!!!
    Jeff Irvin recently posted..Ironman Mont-Tremblant Training Week #1My Profile

  46. Baaaahh that looks so cold, not into the whole ice bath thing when we run in an ice bath out here!
    Ed recently posted..A shlushy slump…My Profile

  47. I used to ice bath but I haven’t in several training seasons. A couple of weeks ago I tried to ice bath after a 60 mile ride…oh so miserable! I prefer a warm Epsom salt bath. I don’t know how well either of them really work for me but I sure enjoy the Epsom salt bath more!
    That Pink Girl recently posted..Treats and SnoozinMy Profile

  48. I’ve never done it, but seems SO painful…

    I like an epson salt bath on occasion but totally less painful!!!
    marissa recently posted..quick fish tacos, waffle sandwiches and more!My Profile

  49. I did ice baths after all my major longs building up to and after Portland. I felt that I recovered great. Then I skipped them for Houston (5 degree runs were cold enough for me) and felt exactly the same.
    No more ice baths for me!
    Kathy R recently posted..One False Start, Followed By My Best 20 Miler … Ever!My Profile

  50. Looking your post made me chilled.
    Liz recently posted..Hcg Diet AcceleratorMy Profile

  51. Why have an ice bath when you can have a beer!!!

    That said if the legs are a bit sore from running to hard, I might rade the Coke truck for a bit of ice to rub the legs down a bit. But I’m with you, if your legs aren’t sore it’s a waste.
    Coach Dion recently posted..107.5 NOT OUTMy Profile

  52. Perhaps it’s just putting more pain on pain, but the legs do tend to feel better after getting out. Just like anything else in the running world-there’s differing of opinion. I’m with you-do what works. Sometimes I think we read too much about this stuff and it gets confusing-I know I do!
    Adrienne recently posted..Adventures in Tri Training: Week 1My Profile

  53. I only take Ice Baths when I get over 15 miles. But I think they help. They aren’t enjoyable, but my post run nap seems to be more relaxing if I do an ice bath. I get restless leg syndrome otherwise.
    Vieve recently posted..Pump ItMy Profile

  54. I never take ice baths. In fact, I’m usually cold after resting from a run (unless it is hot weather) that I need heat heat heat! And I, knock on wood, have been running injury free for months now. I think everyone is different? I do get a regular sports chiro adjustment each month, plus obsessively stretch/foam roll after each run. But, for the most part, haven’t found need or desire for a frigid dunk. :-)
    Christina Williams recently posted..Travel: Always missing GermanyMy Profile

  55. I have actually never taken an ice bath! I think I’m too scared to try :) I do swear by soaking in Epsom salts though.
    Beth @ RUNNING around my kitchen recently posted..5 things Friday…on SundayMy Profile

  56. I’m of the same opinion – if they work for you, do it; otherwise, I have found that leg compression sleeves for an hour or so after my run help a lot. Epsom salt baths the night of a race or long run and a very short recovery run the next day are what work well for me.
    David H. recently posted..A solid start to 2012My Profile

  57. Studies have shown that cold water baths are just as effective as ice baths and less pain full

  58. Ice baths are used by the elites and when there is conflicting science, it is generall safe to follow the elites. However, all should check out this article by Exercise Physiologist Steve Magness who suggests NOT taking an ice bath after your run as it stunts your adaptation benefits but to only use it as a recovery tool before competition.

    http://runningtimes.com/Print.aspx?articleID=21202

    Aaron Paige
    Certified Personal Trainer, Blogger and Avid Runner
    @ApapapaPaige
    Aaron Paige recently posted..Review of the Seeds: Hemp, Flaxseed and ChiaMy Profile

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Are Ice Baths Really Effective? – The whole running world seems to be training for their spring races right now, so Amanda’s question is very timely! [...]

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge